I blogged a week or so ago that I was engaged in trying to save a very historic house here in my hometown. This entire effort has been one big roller coaster ride, good news one day, awful news the next. The biggest problem we have been experiencing is mere anecdotal evidence of its original occupants from someone who lived back around the time it was built and remembered them living there. What would seal the whole thing would be if we could find legal documents like deeds and such that would prove once and for all who built and owned this house. I do have friends researching that information for me but whether or not we can come up with it is yet another story altogether. For now, we must rely on the word of a local historian who lived in the early part of the 20th century and was alive at the time this house was constructed and remembered the family who lived there, the daughter and son-in-law of the man whose family would eventually give this town its name. This house's ties to the the founding family of our town makes it, in my opinion, a significant piece of local history that I strongly believe ought to be saved. Compared to grander houses of a later period, this one is rather simple and unremarkable to the untrained eye and that is exactly the opinion of those who will decide this house's fate, that it's not particularly worth saving because it's nothing special. However, these people do not know their architectural history and why this house must be saved. To begin with, it is the only two story mid-19th century Greek Revival house still standing in our town. That in itself warrants saving it, but its ties to some significant personages in our local history makes it extra special. Not only did members of the founding family of our town once live here, but so did a Civil War surgeon, Dr. Aaron M. Sherman, who also helped to found the local Masonic lodge, the Universalist Church that is still in operation today as the Unitarian Universalist Church and the local Medical Society. He also served in the Ohio General Assembly, so he was a state legislator as well, pretty significant if you ask me. Sherman was said to have been at Ford's Theatre the night that Lincoln was shot, and his being a surgeon, this has me wondering if he at all offered any medical help to the President. If he did, that would give this house additional historical value.
I find the doorway of this house to be of interest, too. It is a robust Greek Revival doorway, with Doric columns, a sturdy lintel, sidelights and a window above the door, all features that are reminiscent of the work of 19th century New England country builder Asher Benjamin, whose work was also very influential throughout the Western Reserve of Ohio, where our town was located. The Western Reserve comprises most of Northeast Ohio and was land bought by the State of Connecticut to be resettled by people from that state. Benjamin came from Connecticut so the architectural styles he pioneered worked their way westward into this part of the state. His work is more prominent in the earlier Federal Style homes but later Greek Revivals bear marks of his influence and this house is no exception. Although the door itself is modern, I am still struck by the handsome framing of this doorway and how it hearkens to a past where symmetry and form were important to home builders. The interior of the home has been modernized considerably over the decades by various tenants and its later incarnation has seen it used as a student rental home, which is highly unfortunate. When the most recent tenants were informed that this house was slated for demolition, they punched enormous holes in the walls and pretty well trashed the interior, sadly. But there is still a fair amount of original woodwork in it and that in itself is remarkable. In the basement can be seen an enormous hand hewn beam with the adze marks still visible. I once attended a lecture given by a timber framer and he took us out to a 19th century barn on a frigid January night and showed us the hewn beams in it and told us that when we touched them, we were touching the hands that hewed the bark off of the trees to create the beams themselves. I love that idea that a beam can be a veritable time machine backward where you can touch a hand that worked a piece of wood that long ago. This is yet another reason that I want to save this house, the fact that it is timber framed, post and beam, the way they did it without the benefit of power tools so long ago. I would love to show future generations how houses were built when our town was young and they had to cut down the trees on the land where they wanted to build a home. So we shall see if this whole effort is successful. A bunch of us are meeting tomorrow morning to discuss strategies for saving it. We shall see what we can brainstorm and come up with. In the meantime, we have at the very least succeeded in staving off the wrecking ball until more research can be done on this historic house's provenance. I personally think that this will be found to be a very significant part of early town history that must be preserved, but maybe I am just being an optimist or something.....I do hope we are successful. Time will tell.
Friday, March 16, 2012
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
Why I Love Caller-ID
One thing that drives me absolutely crazy is the non-stop telephone calls I get around the dinner hour and beyond. In fact, some nights the phone doesn't stop ringing until well after 9 p.m. Thank goodness I have Caller-ID. Yes, this costs extra, but it allows me to screen my calls and to avoid talking to the nightly parade of people looking to part me from my money. No matter how many times I register my phone number with DoNotCall.gov, it doesn't seem to stop people from calling me to sell me everything from home security systems to homeowner's insurance to replacement windows to telling me that I have won a cruise (yeah, right, do you really expect me to believe that?). First off, I am not a homeowner, I merely rent a tiny apartment in a century home owned by someone else. So why I get so many calls about things like home security systems and other things that the average homeowner might want is beyond me. How I got on to somebody's call list and how I get off of it is anybody's guess. I even get those calls on my cell phone, which I have also registered with DoNotCall.gov, but my phone numbers must be immune from telemarketers, politicians and other do-gooders wanting to part me from my money. I just don't get it. Why I get the endless stream of calls night after night after night, starting about the time I walk in the door from work and not ending until well after 9 p.m. is a mystery to me. I also get the inevitable robo-calls around election time urging me to vote for (_________fill in the blank) and the reasons why I should support said candidate. Ah, well, it's a dirty business, I suppose, and in this era of high joblessness, the poor schmucks who must spend their nights dialing for dollars are probably just desperate souls wanting to make an honest buck in a lousy economy, but please, may I ask you to just cease and desist with calling my number a half dozen times a night? If I don't answer the first time, GIVE UP! I'm not going to answer, so stop trying, already! Don't waste your time on me, it's not going to work! So if you're one of those poor benighted souls who is forced to spend their nights in a calling center dialing for dollars, just remember, don't call me, don't even try, I have Caller-ID and I know how to use it, to avoid listening to your prewritten script about whatever it is you are trying to get me to do in order to give you my money. Not gonna happen. Not now, not ever. Thank you for listening. Now, can I please just go back to reading my book?
Monday, March 5, 2012
A longshot attempt to save a historic home
Here where I live, the recently hired President of the University seems intent on making over our town in his own image of what it should look like, meaning massive demolition of entire sections of town to build monstrosities that for some of us serve no purpose other than to demolish entire neighborhoods. I am hearing from people who work there that this particular President wants to elevate our University to a Tier 1 status a la Ohio State, but Columbus is a far bigger city and far better able to handle massive landscape changes than we in our small town can deal with. Nonetheless, demolition of entire neighborhoods continues to go forward, and one home standing in the path of it all is this historic home dating from sometime around the mid-19th century. An architect friend of mine calls it one of the finest examples of Greek Revival architecture left in the city and he's a valuable ally to have in this fight to save it. The reason that the University wants to demolish it is to build this ridiculous "Esplanade", which is supposed to be some sort of walkway that makes it easier for the college students to walk downtown, as if they ever had any problem at all. Since the University doesn't have classes anymore on Friday (which I find terribly odd, given the skyrocketing cost of tuition), the parties go on not just Friday and Saturday night, but on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays now, so for three nights in a row, I see students migrating downtown from both off-campus housing and from the dorms on campus. They seem to have no difficulty whatsoever getting to the bars on weekend nights, so why they need this "Esplanade" is beyond me. It's going to be nothing but a trash magnet and a nuisance to the city, filled with drunken students who will leave it strewn with beer cans and beer bottles that somebody's going to have to clean up. Who, I do not know, but somebody.
The house we are trying to save has a very strong possibility of being of significant historic value. It might have been the residence of a Dr. Aaron M. Sherman, a physician, a Captain in the Civil War who served as a battlefield surgeon at the Lincoln General Hospital in Washington, DC, a founder of the First Universalist Church here in town, now the Unitarian Universalist Church, and an all around mover and shaker in this area. According to one report I read, he was at Ford's Theatre in Washington the night that Lincoln was shot, which is very significant indeed, especially given that he was a doctor. I don't suppose he rushed to the stricken President's side, but who knows, maybe he did. Just the fact that he was there that night makes Dr. Sherman a historic figure in town, and if it can be proven that this was his house, its saving is even more important. I had coffee with an architect friend on Saturday morning to discuss what steps are going to need to be taken to save it and yes, it's a longshot, to be sure, but we've got to try. I couldn't live with myself if I didn't do anything to try to preserve this beautiful old house. I hope that we're successful in saving it, but in the meantime, I have my work cut out for me. There will be many hoops to jump through, many steps that will need to be taken, many people I will need to contact and work with. Things are already in motion but we've only just begun the first steps in what will no doubt be a long process to save this beautiful historic home from the wrecking ball. We have two months before it comes down, not much time, but enough time to maybe convince the University that it is in their best interest to save a historic landmark and preserve a piece of our rapidly disappearing local history. Stay tuned.....it's going to be a long and uphill battle.
The house we are trying to save has a very strong possibility of being of significant historic value. It might have been the residence of a Dr. Aaron M. Sherman, a physician, a Captain in the Civil War who served as a battlefield surgeon at the Lincoln General Hospital in Washington, DC, a founder of the First Universalist Church here in town, now the Unitarian Universalist Church, and an all around mover and shaker in this area. According to one report I read, he was at Ford's Theatre in Washington the night that Lincoln was shot, which is very significant indeed, especially given that he was a doctor. I don't suppose he rushed to the stricken President's side, but who knows, maybe he did. Just the fact that he was there that night makes Dr. Sherman a historic figure in town, and if it can be proven that this was his house, its saving is even more important. I had coffee with an architect friend on Saturday morning to discuss what steps are going to need to be taken to save it and yes, it's a longshot, to be sure, but we've got to try. I couldn't live with myself if I didn't do anything to try to preserve this beautiful old house. I hope that we're successful in saving it, but in the meantime, I have my work cut out for me. There will be many hoops to jump through, many steps that will need to be taken, many people I will need to contact and work with. Things are already in motion but we've only just begun the first steps in what will no doubt be a long process to save this beautiful historic home from the wrecking ball. We have two months before it comes down, not much time, but enough time to maybe convince the University that it is in their best interest to save a historic landmark and preserve a piece of our rapidly disappearing local history. Stay tuned.....it's going to be a long and uphill battle.
Sunday, March 4, 2012
What makes a Rembrandt, a Rembrandt?
A friend and I went up to Cleveland today to an exhibit called "Rembrandt in America", the largest single collection of paintings either by Rembrandt, or attributed to him, or by followers of him, or his circle, ever assembled. We opted to use the audio tour that is available and I was astonished at how much I learned listening to the lectures on some of the paintings. We both found that we learned how to ascertain which paintings were actually by Rembrandt and which ones weren't, and which ones were problematic in their attribution to Rembrandt. One thing that amazed me was how some paintings had been altered by cleanings, retouchings and conservators over time, including the one on the left, which is one of the more problematic paintings in the entire exhibition because it was donated to the museum in not very great condition and suffered at the hands of poor conservators over the years. There is an extensive mini-exhibit of the problems associated with this painting and the various ways in which it has been damaged and retouched over the years. One of the scientific examinations of it appears to show the woman's mouth slightly open and her teeth showing, as opposed to the way we see it here. No mention is made of that in the exhibit but my friend and I swore we could see a change in the mouth of the subject, possibly done by the hand of a bad conservator or something. It left us both wondering what it was we were looking at and whether we were correct in assuming that the painting had been changed over time, throwing its original painter in doubt. I also found myself wondering later why Rembrandt, of all the Dutch Masters, had such a following that so many imitated his work to where paintings began being attributed to him that were not his at all, but by people in his circle, or his followers, or his students. What about the other Dutch Masters?
During the Gilded Age, collecting Rembrandts became a mark of prestige and robber barons snapped up paintings that they assumed were by the great master himself. Turns out not all of them were authentic Rembrandts and many were by his followers, his circle and his students. Some were authentic Rembrandts but not all of them. I don't know what it was about this particular painter that attracted such a desire to own his work, as opposed to anyone else, but apparently this painter's works were hot on the art market and became a highly desired commodity. Perhaps acquiring a Rembrandt became an outward sign of affluence. I am beginning to think that I need to learn more art history than I learned in college. One remarkable exhibit we went to that was kind of associated with the main one of his paintings was an exhibit of Rembrandts prints, which were fascinating. I knew he did prints but I was astonished by the variety of them and the ways he varied them by taking the same print and then changing them to emphasize different things in the print. The collection that was on display was from the collection of J. Pierpont Morgan, another one of the industrial barons of the early 20th century who had the money to acquire great works of art. I just wish I understood why Rembrandt in particular was so special to the industrial barons of 100 years ago and why there was such a mad race to acquire his work as opposed to, say, Vermeer or some other contemporary of Rembrandt. There must have been something about this particular artist that aroused such a passion for collecting his work. It was just so fascinating to become better acquainted with him as an artist than I previously had been and to share that with someone who loves art as much as I do. All in all a very good, albeit very exhausting, day was had, and I am glad for it. I don't get up to the Cleveland Museum of Art nearly enough even though I have a membership there, and we in NE Ohio are very blessed to have a world class art museum in our own backyard. Thanks to the industrial barons of nearly a century ago, Cleveland is blessed with cultural treasures that rival those found in far larger cities, and all of Northeast Ohio benefits from the 1% of the Gilded Age. Too bad today's 1% are not as civically minded as that class was a hundred or so years ago.
During the Gilded Age, collecting Rembrandts became a mark of prestige and robber barons snapped up paintings that they assumed were by the great master himself. Turns out not all of them were authentic Rembrandts and many were by his followers, his circle and his students. Some were authentic Rembrandts but not all of them. I don't know what it was about this particular painter that attracted such a desire to own his work, as opposed to anyone else, but apparently this painter's works were hot on the art market and became a highly desired commodity. Perhaps acquiring a Rembrandt became an outward sign of affluence. I am beginning to think that I need to learn more art history than I learned in college. One remarkable exhibit we went to that was kind of associated with the main one of his paintings was an exhibit of Rembrandts prints, which were fascinating. I knew he did prints but I was astonished by the variety of them and the ways he varied them by taking the same print and then changing them to emphasize different things in the print. The collection that was on display was from the collection of J. Pierpont Morgan, another one of the industrial barons of the early 20th century who had the money to acquire great works of art. I just wish I understood why Rembrandt in particular was so special to the industrial barons of 100 years ago and why there was such a mad race to acquire his work as opposed to, say, Vermeer or some other contemporary of Rembrandt. There must have been something about this particular artist that aroused such a passion for collecting his work. It was just so fascinating to become better acquainted with him as an artist than I previously had been and to share that with someone who loves art as much as I do. All in all a very good, albeit very exhausting, day was had, and I am glad for it. I don't get up to the Cleveland Museum of Art nearly enough even though I have a membership there, and we in NE Ohio are very blessed to have a world class art museum in our own backyard. Thanks to the industrial barons of nearly a century ago, Cleveland is blessed with cultural treasures that rival those found in far larger cities, and all of Northeast Ohio benefits from the 1% of the Gilded Age. Too bad today's 1% are not as civically minded as that class was a hundred or so years ago.
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
And the winner is.....
This year's Academy Awards had a decidedly French flavor to it, with several films that featured either Paris, France or French actors in them. "Hugo", nominated for 11 Oscars, takes place in Paris in 1931. "Midnight in Paris", is Woody Allen's film about a writer visiting Paris who is magically transported back to 1920's Paris and who gets to meet his literary heroes, Ernest Hemingway, Gertrude Stein and F. Scott Fitzgerald. He falls in love with a woman from the 1920s who would rather go back to La Belle Époque when painters like Edgar Degas were working, so they visit that time period and she decides to stay there instead. The whole theme of the movie is that we are never satisfied with where we are and seem to cast a longing and nostalgic eye back at times in which we think we'd rather live. This movie also garnered some Oscar nominations. Then there was "The Artist", starring French actors Jean Dujardin and Berenice Bejo in a black and white silent movie about a fading silent film star (Dujardin) and a rising young talkie star (Bejo). It was a charming nod to film history, as was the movie "Hugo", which is about a young boy who was restoring an old automaton with his father when he is left suddenly orphaned and goes to live with a drunken uncle at a Paris train station. The uncle disappears and Hugo must live by his wits, stealing to survive. He steals parts from a toy store in the train station to continue repair of the automaton. The toy store is run by a bitter old man who turns out to have been the former owner of the automaton and who was once a renowned pioneer filmmaker, Georges Méliès. The intersection of their two lives serves to bring Monsieur Méliès back to public recognition again when he thought that he had been long forgotten. It's a charming movie that I saw three times and would happily see again. Well, the night's big honors went to "The Artist", which took home 5 Academy Awards, including Best Actir, Best Director, Best Movie, Best Costuming and Best Musical Score. "Hugo" took home 5 Oscars, too, but mostly for technical achievement, no big surprise, given the wizardry involved in bringing that film to life. Still, I thought that Martin Scorsese would win for Best Director at least. What he did with "Hugo" was nothing short of miraculous. It was a dazzling feast for the eyes and a very heartwarming story as well. It was also way out of Scorsese's usual comfort zone of films that seem to explore the nature of violence. "Hugo" was the very antithesis of that, a gentle, magical family story of redemption and the magical power of cinema. But it seemed like this past year was a real banner year for superlative filmmaking. I saw a lot of first rate films, many of which were vying for Oscar honors, so the competition this year was particularly stiff for just about every category. I do hope this trend of high quality movies continues into this new year. The only trouble is that they do not make it to our local theatres here and we often have to drive to Cleveland to see the really good movies. But it's a small price to pay to see some outstanding movies!
Monday, February 20, 2012
Farewell, Downton Abbey, until next year!
I have to admit to having become a dyed-in-the-wool "Downton Abbey" addict. Not since PBS's other Edwardian series "Upstairs, Downstairs" back in the early 1970s has a show so captivated me, but this one is so much more complex than that series ever was. Each character has his or her own story and we get to know a very large cast of characters, from the upstairs residents in the household of the Earl of Grantham to his downstairs staff of maids, footmen, the butler, the valet and others. This series starts a bit later than "Upstairs" did, which, if memory serves, starts in around 1902 and goes through the 1920s. "Downton" starts with the sinking of the Titanic and the fact that the only heir to the Earldom of Grantham perished when that ship went down, forcing Lord Robert Crawley, Earl of Grantham, to seek an unlikely heir in a distant cousin, a middle class lawyer from Manchester named Matthew Crawley, who arrives at the estate with his mother to learn the ways of nobility, and the story takes off from there with love interests, scandals, deaths and other things. The first season ends with war being declared on Germany, the beginning of World War I. The second season takes the family and the household through that great war and the effect it has on everyone, as social classes begin to break down and the world is, as a result, forever changed. Nobody is left unscathed in the household, neither servant nor the upstairs residents. We say goodbye to some characters, meet other new ones and watch as Matthew, the presumptive heir to Downton, further has his life turned upside down as he goes off to fight the great war. There is an off again, on again romance with the Earl's eldest daughter, Mary that keeps things constantly interesting. It's a totally addictive series and seems to have developed an international following. It's become PBS's big hit of the year and has won numerous awards as well. Watching PBS has become cool again, especially if you're a huge fan of this period drama.
It owes a lot to its predecessor, "Upstairs, Downstairs", which was another series that took place around the same period and aired back in the early 1970s. I was a big fan of that show as well and followed it religiously. That show begins in 1902 and follows both sets of people through the 1920s, so it covers a lot of ground, including the sinking of the Titanic and World War I. "Downton Abbey" starts with the Titanic and so far, has taken us to the year 1920. Season 3 promises to take the household through at least the opening years of the 1920s and should have some interesting material to cover as well. There are several fascinating storylines that are still up in the air and we have yet to find out what happens to certain characters who have been left in suspense as Season 2 ended. Unfortunately, Season 3 won't air in the US until January of 2013, so we have a very long wait to find out what is going to happen next. I suppose a big part of what has endeared this show to so many viewers is the character of Violet, the Dowager Countess and mother to Lord Robert Crawley, Earl Grantham. She has a sharp tongue and responds to so many situations with absolutely hilarious lines. For example, in the first season, when she learns of a scandal involving her eldest granddaughter, she wonders if she shouldn't take her abroad to Rome or someplace to find her a potential husband, telling her daughter-in-law, the current Countess, Lady Cora Crawley, "In these moments, you can always find an Italian who isn't too picky!" Violet is played by the splendid actress Dame Maggie Smith, who plays it for all it's worth. I understand that Shirley MacLaine will be joining the Season 3 cast as Lady Cora's American mother, Martha Levinson, which promises to provide plenty of fireworks between her and the Dowager Countess! I wish the wait for the new season was not so long, but I suppose in the meantime I will have to buy the DVDs and watch the first two seasons again (I understand that it is best to buy the uncut British versions instead of the American ones, from what I hear from the fan base!). Well, Downton Abbey, it's been quite a ride, and I so look forward to a reunion with the amazing cast of this show next year.
It owes a lot to its predecessor, "Upstairs, Downstairs", which was another series that took place around the same period and aired back in the early 1970s. I was a big fan of that show as well and followed it religiously. That show begins in 1902 and follows both sets of people through the 1920s, so it covers a lot of ground, including the sinking of the Titanic and World War I. "Downton Abbey" starts with the Titanic and so far, has taken us to the year 1920. Season 3 promises to take the household through at least the opening years of the 1920s and should have some interesting material to cover as well. There are several fascinating storylines that are still up in the air and we have yet to find out what happens to certain characters who have been left in suspense as Season 2 ended. Unfortunately, Season 3 won't air in the US until January of 2013, so we have a very long wait to find out what is going to happen next. I suppose a big part of what has endeared this show to so many viewers is the character of Violet, the Dowager Countess and mother to Lord Robert Crawley, Earl Grantham. She has a sharp tongue and responds to so many situations with absolutely hilarious lines. For example, in the first season, when she learns of a scandal involving her eldest granddaughter, she wonders if she shouldn't take her abroad to Rome or someplace to find her a potential husband, telling her daughter-in-law, the current Countess, Lady Cora Crawley, "In these moments, you can always find an Italian who isn't too picky!" Violet is played by the splendid actress Dame Maggie Smith, who plays it for all it's worth. I understand that Shirley MacLaine will be joining the Season 3 cast as Lady Cora's American mother, Martha Levinson, which promises to provide plenty of fireworks between her and the Dowager Countess! I wish the wait for the new season was not so long, but I suppose in the meantime I will have to buy the DVDs and watch the first two seasons again (I understand that it is best to buy the uncut British versions instead of the American ones, from what I hear from the fan base!). Well, Downton Abbey, it's been quite a ride, and I so look forward to a reunion with the amazing cast of this show next year.
Monday, February 13, 2012
Contraception and Healthcare
I was raised Roman Catholic and when I was growing up going to Mass at St. Patrick's every Sunday, it wasn't uncommon to see families of 10-12 kids taking up an entire pew. They usually had one in every grade in school, meaning that mom was pregnant at least once a year to have them spaced a year apart in age. Until my cousin Terry died of cancer several years ago, I had 22 first cousins on my mom's side. She is the middle of five children and her siblings all had fairly large families. That was the norm during the Baby Boom years, I suppose, but the moreso in Catholic families where birth control has been a big no-no since, well, I don't know when. Now that the Obama health care plan includes contraceptive care for women, Catholic bishops are raising the red flag and saying that it's a violation of religious liberty to make religious employers provide contraceptive care when it violates their moral belief. The Obama administration has had to do some delicate side stepping in order to cool the fires, but the bishops are still displeased and think that anyone working for a Catholic organization should be exempt from access to birth control, Catholic or no. Part of what caused me to leave the Catholic Church decades ago was my disagreement with their stance on women's reproductive issues.
When I reached my reproductive years, and I was late in coming to them, I considered using birth control pills to ameliorate miserable monthly symptoms that were nearly incapacitating. The Catholic Church wouldn't even allow it in cases where someone's health was at stake, and I began to realize that there was nothing at all in the Bible that said you couldn't exercise birth control or even take it as medication to alleviate severe pain like I was having. I also saw the effects of lack of birth control in Central America when my older sister went down to Nicaragua in 1974 after the terrible earthquake down there that ravaged that country. She returned home with pictures of wrenching poverty caused by overpopulation and I knew then that the Church in which I was raised was wrong and should do something about that. Overpopulation due to lack of access to birth control is a health care issue. It's wrong and it's unsustainable in the long term. It ticks me off that the bishops are using this as a political tool against the President of the United States, an office that seems to have lost a great deal of respect in recent years. The issue of birth control has now become a political football that will continue to be kicked from now until the elections in November. It's interesting how 98% of American Catholic women use birth control and how much smaller families are now than they were 50 years ago, when it was common to see a brood of 10-12 kids in a single family. By and large, American Catholics tend to be far more liberal than their European or Latin American counterparts. I just wonder how people will respond to the firestorm being brewed by the bishops. Will Catholics side with them while taking the pill behind their backs, or will they realize that this is a women's health care issue and that when push comes to shove, nobody is forcing anybody to take birth control pills if they truly don't believe in doing so? And that's what is at the crux of all this. It isn't as if the Obama administration is mandating that women take birth control. It's merely the idea that if a woman wishes to do so, her insurance carrier should provide her with access to it IF SHE WANTS TO DO SO. Now, why the bishops are making such a kerfuffle over this, I don't know, but it strikes me as odd that the loudest voices against women having control over their own bodies is men. That just goes to show that while women have made great strides, we have so much further to go yet. We don't really have the control over our bodies that we should have. At the end of the day, insurance and government tell us what we can and cannot do and I regard that as a crying shame.
When I reached my reproductive years, and I was late in coming to them, I considered using birth control pills to ameliorate miserable monthly symptoms that were nearly incapacitating. The Catholic Church wouldn't even allow it in cases where someone's health was at stake, and I began to realize that there was nothing at all in the Bible that said you couldn't exercise birth control or even take it as medication to alleviate severe pain like I was having. I also saw the effects of lack of birth control in Central America when my older sister went down to Nicaragua in 1974 after the terrible earthquake down there that ravaged that country. She returned home with pictures of wrenching poverty caused by overpopulation and I knew then that the Church in which I was raised was wrong and should do something about that. Overpopulation due to lack of access to birth control is a health care issue. It's wrong and it's unsustainable in the long term. It ticks me off that the bishops are using this as a political tool against the President of the United States, an office that seems to have lost a great deal of respect in recent years. The issue of birth control has now become a political football that will continue to be kicked from now until the elections in November. It's interesting how 98% of American Catholic women use birth control and how much smaller families are now than they were 50 years ago, when it was common to see a brood of 10-12 kids in a single family. By and large, American Catholics tend to be far more liberal than their European or Latin American counterparts. I just wonder how people will respond to the firestorm being brewed by the bishops. Will Catholics side with them while taking the pill behind their backs, or will they realize that this is a women's health care issue and that when push comes to shove, nobody is forcing anybody to take birth control pills if they truly don't believe in doing so? And that's what is at the crux of all this. It isn't as if the Obama administration is mandating that women take birth control. It's merely the idea that if a woman wishes to do so, her insurance carrier should provide her with access to it IF SHE WANTS TO DO SO. Now, why the bishops are making such a kerfuffle over this, I don't know, but it strikes me as odd that the loudest voices against women having control over their own bodies is men. That just goes to show that while women have made great strides, we have so much further to go yet. We don't really have the control over our bodies that we should have. At the end of the day, insurance and government tell us what we can and cannot do and I regard that as a crying shame.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









